A recent House Foreign Affairs report on the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan has drawn intense criticism, particularly from Republican Senator Joni Ernst, who lamented the tragic loss of 13 service members and the abandonment of over 1000 Americans and vulnerable Afghans. The report claims that the Biden administration ignored military advice and stuck to a predetermined withdrawal timeline, leading to significant consequences including the loss of military equipment. However, White House national security spokesperson John Kirby dismissed the report as rehashing previously known issues, stating it provided no new insights and criticizing the timing of the GOP's release. The State Department defended its actions during the chaotic withdrawal, arguing that the report cherry-picked facts and failed to acknowledge the complexities of the situation. It emphasized that the decision to initiate a noncombatant evacuation operation was made late, just as the Taliban entered Kabul. The ongoing debate highlights the stark divisions in perspectives regarding the handling of the Afghanistan withdrawal and its aftermath.