Robert Irwin’s DWTS Wicked Night Jazz Performance Sparks Fan Controversy Nationwide

Robert Irwin, a contestant on Dancing With the Stars Season 34, delivered a jazz performance themed around the musical Wicked, portraying the character Fiyero. Paired with professional dancer Witney Carson, Irwin impressed the judges with ambitious choreography and strong stage presence, earning a collective score of 36 out of 40 from the panel that included guest judge Jon M. Chu, director of Wicked: For Good. Despite the high scores, many fans felt Irwin deserved perfect tens, expressing their enthusiasm on social media and praising both his dancing and his emerald Fiyero-inspired costume. The episode featured routines by all remaining couples set to songs from the Wicked franchise, celebrating the upcoming film sequel, with the official Wicked film Instagram also endorsing Irwin's look. Although Irwin's score placed him slightly behind other top performers that night, his performance was noted for its energetic moves including a notable dolphin dive and a floor slide. Dancing With the Stars airs live weekly on ABC and Disney+, with the season finale scheduled for November 25.