Former Defenders Reveal Underrated Newcastle, Sunderland Players

Former Newcastle defender John Anderson and former Sunderland defender Darren Williams have each named their top five most underrated players for their respective clubs in the 21st century. Anderson's Newcastle selections include Andy Griffin, Kevin Gallacher, Shola Ameobi, and Sean Longstaff, recognizing their consistent work ethic and resilience despite criticism and high expectations. Williams highlighted Lee Cattermole for his leadership and Chris Maguire for his contributions at Sunderland, though some fans questioned Maguire's inclusion. The lists have sparked debate among supporters, with some nominating Gavin McCann and Alex Rae as alternative underrated Sunderland players. Both defenders stressed the value of unsung players who made significant contributions but were often overshadowed by star teammates. The discussion reflects ongoing appreciation for players whose efforts may have been overlooked.