Colts Face Quarterback Uncertainty, Mixed 2025 Outlook

The Indianapolis Colts are entering the 2025 NFL season with significant roster changes and mounting expectations, particularly around their quarterback situation involving Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones. The team has added versatile tight end Tyler Warren, who is expected to be a contributor though not an immediate star, and bolstered their defense with key free agent signings such as Charvarius Ward and Camryn Bynum. Behind star running back Jonathan Taylor, rookie DJ Giddens and Tyler Goodson are expected to compete for backup roles, with veteran Khalil Herbert's roster spot in question despite a recent $1.3 million signing. Analysts offer contrasting forecasts for the Colts’ 2025 performance, with some predicting a modest 8-9 record that may fall short of playoff contention, while others foresee a potential disastrous 4-13 outcome due to quarterback struggles and other team weaknesses. The key to the Colts’ success will hinge on improvement at quarterback and how the new additions integrate into the team under head coach Shane Steichen.