ESPN Experts Predict NFL Defensive, Offensive Rookies of Year for 2025 Season

Several NFL rookies are drawing early praise as potential award winners for the 2025 season. Darius Alexander, drafted by the New York Giants, is expected to bolster their defensive interior alongside Dexter Lawrence, with analysts highlighting his strength, versatility, and potential to exceed expectations. Jacksonville Jaguars' rookie running back Bhayshul Tuten is considered a sleeper candidate for Offensive Rookie of the Year due to his speed, dual-threat capabilities, and the opportunity presented by the Jaguars’ evolving backfield. On defense, Derrick Harmon of the Pittsburgh Steelers is a strong contender for Defensive Rookie of the Year, praised for his pressure rate, pass-rushing skills, and fit within a strong Steelers defensive front, although interior linemen rarely win the award. Meanwhile, college football analyst Todd McShay projects Ohio State safety Caleb Downs as the top prospect for the 2026 NFL Draft, noting his rare combination of mental sharpness and physical talent that could make him an elite defensive player. These evaluations reflect a mix of high expectations for rookies and upcoming draft prospects shaping the NFL's future talent landscape.