NFL Teams Show Mixed Results in 2025 Offseason Grades

Several NFL teams have had mixed reviews regarding their 2025 offseason moves. The Pittsburgh Steelers received a low grade from Bleacher Report, criticized for essentially replacing key players with less impactful ones despite a defensive-oriented draft, though some argue their acquisitions of Derrick Harmon, Kaleb Johnson, and DK Metcalf were upgrades. The Seattle Seahawks underwent significant changes, including trading quarterback Geno Smith and wide receiver DK Metcalf, and signing Sam Darnold and Cooper Kupp; analysts view these moves as risky but see potential in their draft picks like Jalen Milroe and Grey Zabel, giving them a mostly mediocre grade overall. The Tennessee Titans completely overhauled their roster, drafting quarterback Cam Ward first overall and signing veterans like Dan Moore Jr. and Tyler Lockett; while Pro Football Focus gave them an average grade, others praised their draft but were lukewarm on free-agent signings, seeing the offseason as a foundation for future improvement if Ward develops into a franchise quarterback.