Yankees Exploit Max Scherzer Pitch-Tipping to Beat Blue Jays

The New York Yankees capitalized on Toronto Blue Jays pitcher Max Scherzer tipping his changeup during a 4-3 victory, with Yankees players signaling each other about the pitch. Aaron Judge, on second base, relayed signals to Ben Rice, who ultimately hit a decisive three-run homer after recognizing the tipped pitches. Blue Jays manager John Schneider publicly acknowledged Scherzer's mistake and the Yankees' adeptness at picking up on such cues, emphasizing that pitchers must better conceal their pitches. Scherzer himself accepted it as part of the game, noting the prevalence of such tactics in 2025. Despite the Yankees' limited hits and several errors, their pregame scouting and in-game communication gave them an edge, helping them cut the AL East deficit to two games. The incident highlights the fine line between legal sign-stealing through visible cues and illicit methods, with the Yankees staying within the rules by using on-field observations rather than off-field technology.