Paul Mitchell, the new sporting director at Newcastle United, has faced backlash for criticizing the club's previous transfer strategy as 'not fit for purpose,' a sentiment that has upset his predecessor Dan Ashworth and former recruitment staff. Mitchell claims the club's transfer model is outdated and requires a data-informed overhaul, especially after a disappointing summer window where only two signings were made totaling £10 million, failing to secure key target Marc Guehi. Fans and club legends like Alan Shearer have expressed frustration over the lack of high-profile acquisitions, leading to speculation that Mitchell's comments might be an attempt to deflect from his own challenges. Meanwhile, Manchester United is reportedly willing to sell struggling winger Antony, who may attract interest from Newcastle as they seek to strengthen their right-wing position. Ten Hag remains supportive of Antony despite his lackluster performance, while Newcastle's interest in him could be seen as a gamble given his underwhelming record in the Premier League. The ongoing tension between Mitchell and Howe over recruitment strategies highlights the challenges Newcastle faces in aligning their transfer philosophy with their ambitions.