Carrie Underwood's American Idol Return Uncertain Amid Pay Dispute, Mixed Reception

Carrie Underwood, who won American Idol season 4 and joined the show as a judge in season 23, is currently uncertain about returning for season 24. Despite initial excitement about her judging role, she faced criticism for being too soft and less dynamic compared to her predecessor Katy Perry, leading to mixed fan reactions. Carrie has expressed struggles balancing her career with motherhood and reportedly received half of Katy Perry's $25 million salary, which she finds unsatisfactory. Showrunner Megan Michaels Wolflick praised Carrie for carving out her own role and providing needed constructive feedback, indicating producers would like her to return. However, Carrie herself remains unsure, weighing the challenges and rewards of continuing as a judge. The decision ultimately lies with her, as she contemplates her priorities between family and career.