AJ McCarron Criticizes Florida State QB Thomas Castellanos Over Alabama Comments

Florida State quarterback Thomas Castellanos, a transfer from Boston College, boldly claimed that Alabama's team is no longer the same without former head coach Nick Saban and expressed confidence in his ability to challenge them in their 2025 season opener. These remarks drew strong criticism from former Alabama quarterback AJ McCarron, who called Castellanos' comments 'stupidity' and highlighted Castellanos' struggles at Boston College, including losing the starting job and being benched by former Alabama assistant Bill O'Brien. McCarron warned that Alabama's defense would expose Castellanos' weaknesses, especially under pressure, and advised him to focus on his performance rather than talk. Additionally, former Alabama running back Trent Richardson and McCarron themselves unintentionally reinforced Castellanos' point by discussing Alabama's recent losses and challenges following Saban's departure. Despite Alabama being a heavy favorite, analysts note that the Crimson Tide is not the same dominant team it was under Saban, and Florida State's improved roster could create an unpredictable matchup in the season opener. The game is set for August 30 in Tallahassee, with Alabama as a 12.5-point favorite.