Padres, Phillies Face Key Pitching Decisions

The San Diego Padres' playoff hopes have faded as reliever Robert Suarez has struggled, prompting analysts like Dennis Lin to recommend letting him test free agency after 2025 due to age and health concerns, with Adrian Morejon a possible replacement as closer. The Padres, who were once close to the Dodgers in the standings, now face tough roster decisions. Meanwhile, the Philadelphia Phillies' Ranger Suarez has delivered ten consecutive quality starts since returning from injury and boasts a sub-2.10 ERA, making him a valuable asset despite his injury history. Former Phillies GM Ruben Amaro Jr. estimates Suarez could secure a contract worth $160–$185 million, but other analysts believe the team may let him walk in favor of internal pitching prospects and to manage payroll. Both Suarez pitchers currently lead their clubs in saves and quality starts. As the offseason approaches, both teams must weigh financial and roster priorities regarding their top pitchers.