Saints Face Scrutiny Over 2025 Draft Picks Including Tyler Shough, Kelvin Banks Jr.

The New Orleans Saints' 2025 NFL Draft class has drawn mixed reactions, especially regarding their second-round selection of quarterback Tyler Shough, who was the third quarterback off the board. While some draft analysts criticized the pick, suggesting the Saints should have chosen edge rusher Donovan Ezeiruaku instead to bolster their pass rush, NFL insiders revealed that multiple teams were targeting Shough and viewed him as a legitimate second-round talent due to his size, arm strength, and football intelligence. The Saints’ first-round pick, offensive tackle Kelvin Banks Jr., received high praise, with an NFC executive comparing him to five-time Pro Bowler Laremy Tunsil, signaling strong potential for immediate impact. Additionally, the Saints found what some consider their best value pick in cornerback Quincy Riley, selected in the fourth round, who offers promise especially after the team lost key defensive backs Marshon Lattimore and Paulson Adebo. Overall, while Shough’s selection remains divisive among fans and analysts, the draft class addresses critical team needs on both sides of the ball and includes several promising prospects that could contribute significantly in the near future.