Newton Criticism of Tua Fuels Dolphins Uncertainty

The Miami Dolphins have started 0-3, and quarterback Tua Tagovailoa has faced scrutiny for underwhelming play and early turnovers, including a recent interception against the Buffalo Bills. Former MVP Cam Newton criticized Tagovailoa on ESPN’s First Take, saying he hasn’t justified his roughly $51–$53 million salary and likening Miami’s problems to off-field “Love Island” drama. At a press conference, Tagovailoa pushed back—"anybody can play quarterback in this league... I want to see anybody on the streets come and play quarterback"—while also admitting he has not played "anywhere near" his expectations this season. Newton escalated the exchange, urging Tua to "let it rip" and saying "anybody can go 0-3," and ESPN commentator Stephen A. Smith and others reproached Tagovailoa for his retort rather than offering a substantive breakdown. The public spat, salary and cap realities, and lingering questions about Tua’s injury history and concussion effects have intensified debate about the futures of both Tagovailoa and coach Mike McDaniel in Miami.