Carrie Underwood Defends Honest Judging on American Idol Season 24

Carrie Underwood, who won American Idol in 2005, has addressed criticism of her judging style during her role as a judge on Season 23 of American Idol in 2025. She explained in interviews that her critiques are intended to help contestants grow and improve, emphasizing that constant praise does not facilitate growth. Underwood acknowledged that some viewers may find her harsh but insisted her feedback comes from a constructive and encouraging place to help contestants become the best version of themselves. She also shared that being authentic and vulnerable on camera remains a challenge for her, as she is naturally a private person, though she has become somewhat more comfortable over time. Underwood replaced Katy Perry as a judge and is expected to return for Season 24 in 2026. Her return to the show, where she began her career, has been described as rewarding, offering her the opportunity to help new singers pursue their dreams.