2025 MLB All-Star Game Sparks Widespread Snub Controversy Across Teams

The 2025 MLB All-Star Game in Atlanta has sparked controversy due to several notable snubs and contentious player selections. Mets outfielder Brandon Nimmo criticized the selection process, highlighting how star players like Juan Soto were excluded despite strong performances, while others with lesser stats were included. Arizona Diamondbacks' shortstop Geraldo Perdomo was also overlooked despite impressive offensive and defensive contributions, with critics noting the National League's depth at shortstop complicates selections. The Philadelphia Phillies expressed frustration over veteran pitcher Cristopher Sanchez being replaced by rookie Jacob Misiorowski, despite Sanchez's superior season statistics, which also led to outrage when Mets' David Peterson was chosen over Sanchez as a replacement. Additionally, Dodgers center fielder Andy Pages was left off the roster despite significant improvement and strong numbers, likely due to the rule requiring at least one player from each team and the Dodgers already having five All-Stars. These disputes underline ongoing dissatisfaction with MLB's All-Star selection procedures amid debates over merit and representation.