New York City Mayor Eric Adams faced public backlash after wearing a hat with both Mets and Yankees logos during the Columbus Day Parade, attempting to remain impartial amidst an ongoing rivalry between the city's baseball teams. The hat, reminiscent of the 2000 Subway Series, was seen as a misguided attempt to appeal to both fanbases, with many New Yorkers expressing disapproval on social media. This controversy comes as Adams deals with more serious issues, including his indictment on bribery and fraud charges, further drawing attention to his political challenges. Some fans humorously suggested the hat choice as an 'impeachable offense,' indicating the depth of sports loyalty in the city. The Mets and Yankees are both competing in their respective league championship series, sparking hopes for another Subway Series. Despite the lighthearted nature of this incident, it highlights the complexity of navigating sports allegiances in a city with such a strong cultural identity.