Usman Nurmagomedov Retains PFL Lightweight Title Amid Controversial Decision Over Paul Hughes

Paul Hughes suffered his second defeat to Usman Nurmagomedov in a closely contested rematch for the PFL lightweight title in Dubai, with the Russian winning by unanimous decision amid significant controversy over the judges' scorecards. The scores of 50-45 and 49-46 were widely criticized by fans and journalists as excessively one-sided, with many calling the scoring damaging to the sport's credibility, while the 48-47 card was considered more reasonable. Hughes, who is from Northern Ireland, has faced harsh criticism from Conor McGregor, who questioned Hughes' Irish identity and made disparaging remarks following their first bout. Despite the verbal attacks, Hughes has downplayed McGregor's comments, suggesting they reflect personal issues and not taking them personally. Nurmagomedov acknowledged the toughness of the fight and expressed respect for Hughes, while the bout itself featured multiple low blows and intense exchanges, with Hughes finishing strongly despite the judges' decision. The contentious scoring and McGregor's comments have fueled ongoing debate within the MMA community regarding Hughes' status and the fairness of recent fights.