Blue Jays Navigate Key Free Agency Moves Amid Star Uncertainty

The Toronto Blue Jays have had a mixed offseason and season performance in 2025. Their major free agent signing, Anthony Santander, has underperformed significantly, hitting only six home runs with a .179 average before a shoulder injury sidelined him, yet the team still leads the AL East due to strong contributions from other players. Star shortstop Bo Bichette rebounded from a poor 2024 to lead the American League in hits again in 2025, increasing his free agency value and making it uncertain whether the Blue Jays can afford to retain him despite being among the top favorites to re-sign him, with other teams like the Detroit Tigers and New York Yankees showing interest. The Yankees are reportedly considering Bichette as a replacement for struggling shortstop Anthony Volpe. Additionally, the Blue Jays are looking at potential offseason pitching reinforcements, including two-time All-Star Framber Valdez from the Astros, as they plan for next season. The team faces critical contract decisions with several key players as they aim to maintain their competitive edge in the playoffs and beyond.