Dolphins Face $99M Cap Hit As Future Of Struggling QB Tagovailoa Remains Uncertain

The Miami Dolphins are facing a critical situation with their starting quarterback, Tua Tagovailoa, whose performance has significantly declined during the 2025 season, leading the league with 11 interceptions. His struggles have prompted speculation about a potential benching or even release, though his massive $212.4 million contract extension signed in 2024 complicates any immediate move due to the severe salary cap penalties involved. The Dolphins have already fired their longtime general manager Chris Grier as the team enters a period of transition, with interim management trading players and considering options behind Tagovailoa, including backups Zach Wilson and rookie Quinn Ewers. Despite the on-field issues and leadership questions, the financial implications make it unlikely that Miami will part ways with Tagovailoa before 2026, when his contract includes a potential out clause. Analysts suggest that if the Dolphins decide to move on from him, a trade would be more financially feasible than a release, though his history of concussions and recent performance may limit trade interest. With the franchise's future uncertain, both Tagovailoa and head coach Mike McDaniel are reportedly competing to retain their roles for the 2026 season.