Jimmy Kimmel Sparks Backlash Comparing Manning Brothers to Menendez Twins at Disney Event

At Disney's 2025 Upfront event, Jimmy Kimmel roasted former NFL players Peyton and Eli Manning for their song-and-dance routine promoting their Hulu series, comparing them unfavorably to convicted murderers Lyle and Erik Menendez. Kimmel quipped that the Mannings were like "two jars of mayonnaise" that "can't sing," adding that their performance was "worse than what the Menendez brothers did," a joke that drew groans from the audience. The Menendez brothers were recently resentenced to life with the possibility of parole for the murder of their parents, making Kimmel's timing controversial. Despite backlash and criticism on social media, some agreed with Kimmel's critique of the Mannings' performance. The Mannings had earlier performed an elaborate number pitching themselves into several Disney shows and later promoted their show "Chad Powers," where they serve as executive producers. Kimmel also used his set to poke fun at Disney CEO Bob Iger.