Judge Dismisses NFL Antitrust Suit Over Merchandise

A federal judge has dismissed without prejudice an antitrust lawsuit brought by Casey’s Distributing Inc. against the NFL, its 32 teams, and Fanatics, alleging monopolization of licensed merchandise distribution. The court found that Casey’s failed to provide sufficient evidence of consumer harm, such as higher prices or reduced choice, emphasizing that antitrust law is designed to protect competition, not individual competitors. Casey’s alleged that exclusive deals, including Fanatics' partnership with Walmart, limited its business and access to platforms like Amazon, but these claims did not meet the legal standard for antitrust injury. The NFL and Fanatics both denied any wrongdoing, while Walmart and Amazon were not named as defendants. The judge set a deadline of July 30, 2025, for Casey’s to amend and refile its complaint if it can address the deficiencies. The outcome leaves the NFL and Fanatics without immediate legal consequences, though the case could continue if refiled.