Australian singer Jimmy Barnes and his son David Campbell were jointly named 'Father of the Year' for 2024 by The Fathering Project, marking the first time the award has been shared between two recipients. While David expressed pride in sharing the honor with his father, many Australians took to social media to criticize the decision, arguing that it favored celebrities over deserving local dads. Critics highlighted Barnes' troubled past as a father, including abandoning David at birth and only acknowledging him later in life, raising questions about the appropriateness of the award. Some commentators emphasized the need to recognize regular fathers who contribute meaningfully to their families and communities. Despite the backlash, there were also supporters who praised the duo's evolving relationship and the importance of their public discussions about fatherhood. The contrasting views underscore the complexities of paternal recognition in contemporary society.