Mahomes, Burrow Unanimously Voted Top NFL Quarterbacks by Coaches, GMs

The 2025 NFL quarterback rankings, compiled from a survey of 50 coaches and executives, place Patrick Mahomes and Joe Burrow in the elite Tier 1, with Mahomes securing his fifth consecutive unanimous selection despite a statistically down year. Mahomes, praised by some as the best quarterback ever, remains a clutch performer with a winning record when trailing in the fourth quarter, while Burrow is recognized for his consistent excellence despite concerns about his team's defense. Josh Allen, the 2024 MVP, is also among the top-tier quarterbacks and is noted for his durability and leadership, though comparisons with Mahomes continue to fuel debate about the league's best player. Analysts like Dan Orlovsky rank Mahomes highly for arm strength, second only to Allen, but suggest other quarterbacks are challenging his dominance in various skill categories. Despite some criticism regarding his per-snap performance, Mahomes' career achievements—including three Super Bowl titles, multiple MVP awards, and record-setting passing milestones—solidify his status at the top of the quarterback hierarchy. The consensus among coaches and executives reflects a narrowing gap between Mahomes and his peers, particularly Burrow, Jackson, and Allen, highlighting a dynamic and competitive quarterback landscape in the NFL.