Ben Affleck celebrated his 52nd birthday without Jennifer Lopez, fueling ongoing divorce rumors. Instead, Jennifer Garner, Affleck’s ex-wife, visited him at his rental home, underscoring their amicable co-parenting relationship. Reports indicate that Affleck and Lopez have been living separately, with Lopez focusing on her career and children, and Affleck prioritizing his sobriety and children. Garner, who has been supportive, visited Affleck amidst his marital troubles with Lopez. The couple has not been seen together publicly since June, and sources have suggested that their marriage is nearing its end. This comes as Lopez shared throwback photos from her own birthday celebration, further hinting at their strained relationship.