Saints Draft Tyler Shough 40th Overall Amid Criticism

The New Orleans Saints have faced widespread criticism after selecting Louisville quarterback Tyler Shough with the 40th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, bypassing higher-profile prospects like Shedeur Sanders and Jalen Milroe. Critics argue that Saints GM Mickey Loomis reached for Shough, who had a college career marked by multiple injuries and only one full season as a starter, with most draft analysts ranking him well below the 40th pick. Supporters point to Shough's strong performance in his lone season at Louisville, where he threw for over 3,100 yards and 23 touchdowns, helping lead the team to a 9-4 record. However, detractors highlight Loomis's history of questionable decisions and suggest that this latest move is emblematic of deeper issues within the Saints' leadership. Shough is projected to sign a four-year, $10.79 million contract and will join a Saints quarterback room already facing uncertainty with Derek Carr's health. While some celebrate Shough's perseverance and college success, the consensus remains that the Saints took an unnecessary risk, potentially at the expense of the franchise's future.