In the opening match of the 2024 MLS Cup Playoffs, New York City FC suffered a 1-0 defeat to FC Cincinnati, with Yamil Asad scoring the only goal in the 51st minute, assisted by Luciano Acosta. NYCFC struggled offensively, managing only six shots compared to Cincinnati's 21, and their hopes were further dampened by the red card issued to defender Tayvon Gray in the second half. The Cityzens will need a win in their next game on November 2 to avoid elimination from the best-of-three series. Cincinnati's goalkeeper, Roman Celentano, made two crucial saves to secure a clean sheet, while Matt Freese had five saves for NYCFC. The match marked a disappointing start for NYCFC after a season filled with offensive potential, as they failed to capitalize on their opportunities in a tightly contested game. The next match will be critical for NYCFC's playoff aspirations, as a loss would end their season prematurely.