Nikki Garcia, formerly known as Nikki Bella, expressed her admiration for the match between Toni Storm and Mariah May at the AEW All In 2024 pay-per-view during her podcast. She described a heartwarming moment with her son, Matteo, as they watched the match together; he was captivated by the wrestlers' entrances and performances. Garcia emphasized the incredible storytelling and athleticism displayed in the match, declaring it a must-watch even for those unfamiliar with wrestling. She noted that the event drew her back into watching wrestling, as she sat through four hours of programming. Garcia also hinted at a possible return to the ring to face Britt Baker, igniting speculation among fans. The match culminated with Mariah May becoming the new AEW Women's World Champion, adding to its significance.