Steelers, T.J. Watt Stalled on Contract Extension Amid Franchise Tensions

Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker T.J. Watt remains one of the NFL's top edge rushers, ranked second behind Myles Garrett in league-wide evaluations, despite a late-season decline in sacks and overall production. Watt's contract negotiations with the Steelers have become contentious, with Watt seeking a deal that surpasses Garrett's $40 million per year, including significant guarantees, a stance the Steelers are reluctant to meet given his age and recent performance downturn. Steelers legend Ben Roethlisberger has publicly expressed concern about the growing tension, warning of "bad blood" and potential holdouts, while emphasizing Watt's importance to the team's identity and urging the organization to invest in him. The negotiation impasse appears rooted in multiple contract details, including guarantees and potential clauses in later years, with Watt's dissatisfaction fueled in part by comparisons to Garrett and previous Steelers contracts. Despite some questions about Watt's long-term future and value relative to his demands, league insiders continue to regard him as a dominant defensive force and critical to Pittsburgh's competitiveness in 2025. The Steelers face a challenging decision balancing financial prudence against retaining a player who embodies their grit and defensive prowess.