Saints Draft Tyler Shough, Rookie QB Competes for Starting Role

The New Orleans Saints' quarterback situation remains unsettled heading into the 2025 NFL season, following the selection of Tyler Shough in the second round of the draft. Shough, who is viewed by some analysts as a potential dark horse for Offensive Rookie of the Year, enters a competition with veteran Derek Carr and second-year quarterback Spencer Rattler. General manager Mickey Loomis and analysts agree that Carr will start if healthy, but Shough could become the starter if Carr's lingering shoulder injury sidelines him. While Shough offers promise and is supported by a talented roster, there are concerns about his readiness given his limited collegiate starting experience and the team's offensive line challenges. Pro Football Focus suggests Shough is among rookies who could win a starting job in training camp, but he is not a lock for the role. The outcome of this competition will shape the Saints' direction for the upcoming season.