Stacker Reports Best Midwest Small Towns Under 5,000 Residents

The Midwest continues to attract attention as a desirable region for living, particularly its small towns across 12 states including Illinois, Indiana, and Missouri. These small towns, typically with populations under 5,000, offer historical sites, natural beauty, and a peaceful lifestyle, combined with a strong sense of community and accessibility to larger cities without urban drawbacks. Rankings by Niche for 2025 and 2026, based on factors like cost of living, school quality, safety, and health resource access, highlight towns such as Meridian Hills, Indiana, known for its upscale residential character and natural features, and Frontenac, Missouri, noted for its rural feel and historic shopping mall. Residents appreciate the balance of tranquility and convenience these towns provide, making them appealing alternatives to metropolitan areas. This trend showcases the Midwest's growing appeal beyond its major cities, emphasizing quality of life in smaller communities.