Inquiry Finds Driver with Dementia Caused Toddler's Death

A fatal accident inquiry has revealed that 91-year-old Edith Duncan, who suffered from undiagnosed frontotemporal dementia, caused a tragic accident that resulted in the death of three-year-old Xander Irvine in June 2020. The inquiry determined that Duncan's inability to perform a routine driving maneuver led to the collision, which could have been prevented if her cognitive abilities had been properly assessed and her driving license revoked. Evidence showed she had illegally parked her car and had cancelled her insurance prior to the incident, indicating her unfitness to drive. Sheriff Principal Nigel Ross emphasized the need for an overhaul of the self-certification system for elderly drivers, suggesting cognitive assessments should be mandatory for those over 80. The report noted that Duncan's dementia symptoms may have been identifiable earlier, which could have led to preventive measures. This incident has sparked a broader discussion about road safety and the regulations governing elderly drivers.