New York Islanders Draft Matthew Schaefer No. 1 Overall 2025 NHL Draft

Matthew Schaefer was selected as the No. 1 overall pick in the 2025 NHL Draft by the New York Islanders, becoming the franchise's highest draft pick since John Tavares in 2009. Despite missing half of the previous season due to a broken clavicle, Schaefer impressed scouts with his strong defensive play for the Erie Otters and his international success with Team Canada. His draft moment was emotional, as he paid tribute to his late mother, Jennifer, who passed away after battling breast cancer, and also honored others close to him who died during the season. Schaefer has been open about channeling the tragedies he faced, including the deaths of his billet mother and the Erie Otters owner, into motivation for his hockey career. He has also shared his experiences with grieving youth, aiming to provide support and hope to others coping with loss. The Islanders and fans alike expressed confidence that Schaefer will live up to the high expectations placed on him as the top pick.