Ryan Murphy Defends 'American Love Story' Carolyn Bessette Styling After Backlash

Ryan Murphy, creator of the upcoming series American Love Story, faced significant backlash over the initial costume reveal for characters Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy and John F. Kennedy Jr., with critics comparing the outfits to fast fashion brands like Zara and Mango rather than the iconic designer pieces Bessette was known for. Murphy explained that the released images were from camera tests and not final wardrobes, clarifying that some items, such as a No. 35 Birkin bag, were borrowed from other departments and do not reflect the final costumes. He emphasized that a dedicated 10-member style advisory board is working to authentically replicate Bessette's wardrobe, including reconstructing her iconic wedding dress and incorporating original vintage pieces. Murphy also defended the actor’s wig and hair styling, which had been criticized as inaccurate. He likened the harsh social media criticism to the unfair scrutiny the real Carolyn Bessette faced during her lifetime and plans to release proper comparisons between the final costumes and real-life photos to address concerns. The show is scheduled to premiere on Valentine’s Day 2026.