Josh Gad Criticizes Casey Nicholaw in Memoir

In his memoir 'In Gad We Trust,' Josh Gad reflects on his experience during the production of 'The Book of Mormon,' revealing a tumultuous relationship with director Casey Nicholaw. Despite Nicholaw's creative prowess that contributed to the show's success, Gad describes the atmosphere as 'completely unpleasant,' citing Nicholaw's lack of social skills and team-building leadership as significant issues. He notes that Nicholaw often directed anger at him, suggesting personal animosity, particularly after the show won nine Tony Awards, when Nicholaw posted critical notes about the cast's performance. Gad's remarks were partly prompted by a recent disparaging comment Nicholaw made about him in a New York Times interview. Ultimately, while Gad acknowledges Nicholaw's talent, he emphasizes the negative impact of the director's behavior on the cast and production. This candid portrayal sheds light on the often challenging dynamics behind a successful Broadway show.