Pirates Undecided on Trading Mitch Keller Amid Multiple MLB Offers

The Pittsburgh Pirates are currently undecided on whether to trade starting pitcher Mitch Keller before the trade deadline, despite strong interest from teams including the Toronto Blue Jays, Yankees, Cubs, and Mets. Keller, who is in the first year of a four-year contract worth $15 million (increasing annually to $20 million), is having one of his best seasons, posting a 3.53 ERA over 125 innings with a career-low walk rate, making him a valuable asset. While the Pirates could receive significant offers, the organization is weighing the benefits of trading Keller for young offensive talent against the long-term advantages of retaining him to strengthen their rotation alongside top prospects like Paul Skenes. The Pirates have not yet reached clarity, with some executives favoring keeping the core intact for future contention and others open to a trade if the right offer materializes. This indecision complicates the Blue Jays’ pursuit of Keller, who appears to be their primary trade target. Ultimately, the Pirates’ decision will hinge on balancing immediate returns with future playoff aspirations for the 2026 season.