NFL Rookies Mason Graham, Tetairoa McMillan Face Most Pressure to Succeed

The 2025 NFL season places significant pressure on rookies Mason Graham of the Cleveland Browns and Tetairoa McMillan of the Carolina Panthers, both viewed as pivotal to their teams' fortunes. Graham, drafted fifth overall after the Browns traded down from the second pick originally expected to select Travis Hunter, faces intense scrutiny as the defensive tackle seen as key to the Browns' uncertain direction between rebuilding and contending. Analysts highlight that Graham may have the most pressure on any non-quarterback rookie due to the Browns passing on Hunter and ongoing quarterback questions. Meanwhile, Panthers' first-round receiver McMillan is expected to be a critical offensive weapon for quarterback Bryce Young, who showed improvement late last season, with the team hoping McMillan's size and speed can provide a much-needed deep threat. McMillan's success is seen as essential for the Panthers to exceed their 6.5 win total prediction and capitalize on a stronger defense featuring Derrick Brown. Both players represent high-stakes investments for their franchises, with performance expectations amplified by draft day decisions and their roles in team rebuilds or contending efforts.