Debate Over Judges' Roles in Legal System

Former Chief Justice of India Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud emphasized the need for robust dialogue between the judiciary and government regarding judicial appointments, cautioning against using judicial power to enforce Collegium recommendations. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court of Canada's decisions following the landmark 'Vavilov' ruling have altered the approach to judicial review, making it easier to challenge subordinate legislation. The ACT Bar Association has publicly criticized Chief Justice Lucy McCallum's comments on juries in sexual assault trials, asserting the importance of jury verdicts and rejecting perceptions of jury error. Additionally, contrasting views on judicial roles have emerged in New Zealand, where Attorney-General Judith Collins advocates for a traditional legal approach, while Chief Justice Dame Helen Winkelmann champions a more progressive judicial role. These discussions highlight ongoing tensions regarding the judiciary's influence and its relationship with the executive and legislative branches. Overall, the legal landscape across countries reflects diverse perspectives on judicial power and accountability.