The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) is currently deliberating on the continuation of two controversial playing conditions from the last domestic season: the Impact Player rule and the two-bouncer rule. The two-bouncer rule, which allows bowlers to deliver two bouncers per over in domestic cricket, was introduced in the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy and IPL, receiving mixed reactions from the cricket community. While some stakeholders support the rule for promoting a balance between bat and ball, others argue it may hinder the development of all-rounders. The BCCI has yet to finalize its decision on these rules before the upcoming SMAT competition, leaving state associations uncertain about the playing conditions. Amidst this confusion, the BCCI has communicated guidelines for other domestic events but has not provided clarity on the SMAT rules. The debate over these rules highlights the challenges the BCCI faces in adapting cricket to modern demands while maintaining the sport's traditional aspects.