During a recent preseason game against the Cincinnati Bengals, Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson displayed both promise and inconsistency, highlighted by an impressive touchdown drive followed by a costly pick-six. Analyst Kirk Herbstreit speculated on the potential for a quarterback controversy, suggesting that if Richardson continues to struggle, veteran Joe Flacco could be considered as a replacement. Despite Richardson's rough start to the game, most analysts assert that he is the team's future and unlikely to lose his starting position, as he is still developing after limited play last season. The Colts’ management, having invested a fifth overall pick in Richardson, remains committed to his growth despite the ups and downs showcased in the preseason. Overall, while Herbstreit raised concerns about Richardson's performance, the consensus is that he will remain the starter barring a dramatic decline in performance.