As Commonwealth leaders convene in Samoa, they plan to defy UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer's refusal to discuss reparations for the transatlantic slave trade. Despite the UK government's stance that reparations are 'not on the agenda,' leaders from Caribbean nations are advocating for a meaningful dialogue on the topic, highlighting its historical significance and ongoing impacts. The draft communique from the summit includes commitments to research and discussions on reparatory justice, which could imply substantial financial liabilities for the UK. Prominent figures, including Frederick Mitchell of the Bahamas, emphasize the need for apologies and reparations as crucial for forging a common future. Starmer continues to focus on immediate challenges like climate change, resisting calls to address historical injustices. The outcome of these discussions may significantly influence perceptions of the Commonwealth's relevance and the UK's colonial legacy.