Derek Carr Retires, Saints Face QB Uncertainty

Derek Carr has retired from the NFL at age 34 due to a shoulder injury that would have required surgery and a long recovery, causing him to forfeit $30 million in salary but retain a $10 million roster bonus. Carr, who played most notably for the Raiders before joining the New Orleans Saints, retires with over 41,000 passing yards and 257 touchdowns but no playoff wins. His departure leaves the Saints with a quarterback group of rookie Tyler Shough, Spencer Rattler, and Jake Haener, none of whom have significant NFL experience. Fans and analysts have questioned the decision to draft Shough over Shedeur Sanders, expressing concerns about the team's competitiveness and potential for a high 2026 draft pick. There is ongoing speculation that the Saints may seek a veteran quarterback such as Teddy Bridgewater or Jameis Winston to add experience or mentorship. Carr's retirement ends a significant chapter for the Saints and sets up a period of uncertainty at quarterback.