Yankees Retain Struggling Volpe, Bench Top Shortstop Caballero Amid Playoff Push

The New York Yankees are facing significant challenges as key players and managerial decisions come under scrutiny amid a tight playoff race. Shortstop Anthony Volpe has struggled offensively, with recent slumps sparking debate over whether he should be sent to Triple-A, though manager Aaron Boone remains supportive, emphasizing Volpe's defensive value despite underwhelming offensive metrics. Meanwhile, the Yankees are criticized for hesitating to promote top prospects like outfielder Spencer Jones, who has excelled in Triple-A but remains sidelined, drawing disapproval from former players like Clint Frazier. Amid these personnel issues, Jose Caballero has emerged as a strong offensive and defensive contributor since his trade to the Yankees, yet Boone continues to favor Volpe in the lineup, raising questions about strategic choices. ESPN analyst Eduardo Pérez highlights the fragile nature of the Yankees' path to the World Series, pointing to the reliance on the health and performance of four star players and contrasting Boone's management unfavorably with Houston Astros' Joe Espada, who is praised for maximizing a depleted roster. Overall, the Yankees' internal debates over player usage and managerial effectiveness underscore the uncertainty surrounding their postseason prospects.