Federal Judge Rejects State Secrets Privilege in Abrego Garcia Wrongful Deportation Case

Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Maryland man mistakenly deported to El Salvador by the Trump administration, remains unable to return to the U.S. despite Supreme Court orders. Federal Judge Paula Xinis criticized the administration for broadly invoking the state secrets privilege to withhold information about efforts, or the lack thereof, to facilitate his return, stating the government has not provided sufficient evidence to justify this claim. The judge expressed frustration over the limited and vague documents presented, emphasizing the need for a clear demonstration of how releasing information would harm U.S. foreign relations. Department of Justice attorneys argued that some material is sensitive or classified and that the administration is complying with court orders, but Judge Xinis highlighted statements from Homeland Security indicating no plans exist to bring Abrego Garcia back. The case has seen contentious exchanges between the judge and government lawyers, with the judge demanding more transparency and warning that mere assertions without evidence are inadequate. Meanwhile, Abrego Garcia’s supporters, including Congressman Glenn Ivey, continue to advocate for his return amid ongoing legal battles.