Giants Dexter Lawrence Tops NFL Defensive Tackle Rankings by Execs, Coaches, Scouts

NFL executives, coaches, and scouts have ranked the top defensive tackles entering the 2025 season, placing New York Giants' Dexter Lawrence as the No. 1 defensive tackle in the league due to his dominant run defense, improved pass rush, and a nine-sack season despite a high double-team rate. Indianapolis Colts' DeForest Buckner earned recognition as the most underrated defensive player and was ranked No. 8, praised for his consistency, technique, length, and leadership, even while missing five games last season. Buckner's impact extends beyond his personal stats, as his presence improves the entire Colts defensive line's performance. Baltimore Ravens' Nnamdi Madubuike was ranked No. 7, noted for his strong tackle and sack totals, Pro Bowl selections, and potential for further growth under new coaching. The rankings reflect a group of elite defensive tackles, with Lawrence leading, followed by Chris Jones, Jalen Carter, Jeffery Simmons, and Quinnen Williams among the top five. These assessments highlight both established stars and rising talents who are expected to make significant impacts in the 2025 NFL season.