French Rugby Authorities Oppose 20-Minute Red Card Proposal

The debate over the proposed 20-minute red card in rugby has intensified, with significant opposition from French rugby authorities, including the FFR and LNR, who argue it may compromise player safety and encourage dangerous play. They maintain that the traditional red card effectively deters unsporting behavior and should not be altered without sufficient evidence. Conversely, national unions from South Africa, Australia, and New Zealand support the change, believing it will enhance the game's excitement by allowing teams to replace a red-carded player after 20 minutes. While some players, like Wales lock Dafydd Jenkins, express concerns that the proposal devalues the red card, others, including Ireland's Caelan Doris, advocate for its trial to balance player safety and game integrity. The conversation reflects broader issues in rugby, particularly regarding head injuries and player welfare, as highlighted by ongoing lawsuits from former players against World Rugby. The global trial of this amendment is anticipated to be a focal point at the upcoming World Rugby meeting in November.