Supreme Court Considers Funding for First Religious Charter School

The Supreme Court's conservative majority appeared open to allowing the creation of Oklahoma's St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School, which would be the nation's first religious charter school funded by taxpayers. Justices debated whether charter schools are fundamentally public or private, a distinction critical to whether religious instruction can be permitted in such institutions. Conservative justices argued that excluding religious groups from operating charter schools could amount to religious discrimination, referencing previous Supreme Court decisions expanding religious access to public benefits. Chief Justice John Roberts emerged as a key figure, expressing skepticism about arguments for excluding religious schools while also noting the greater state involvement in charter schools compared to prior cases. The outcome could have national implications, potentially opening the door for religious charter schools across the country and prompting states to consider new regulations for charter programs. With Justice Amy Coney Barrett recused, the decision may hinge on a single conservative justice if the court's liberals are united in opposition.