MLB All-Quarter Century Team Overlooks Giants, Tigers Legends

Jayson Stark of The Athletic named Yadier Molina the best catcher of the first 25 years of the 21st century, highlighting his exceptional defensive skills and longevity, with nine Gold Gloves and two World Series titles. However, the debate includes San Francisco Giants' Buster Posey and Twins' Joe Mauer, who were stronger hitters and had higher overall value metrics, with Posey arguably having the better peak and career despite Molina's superior defense. Meanwhile, young Yankees catcher Austin Wells is excelling defensively, ranking in the 98th percentile in pitch framing, but struggles offensively with a low batting average and poor plate discipline, resulting in a diminished role in the lineup. The Detroit Tigers have benefited from strong contributions but face concerns over second baseman Gleyber Torres, who despite solid offensive numbers, may miss more time due to lower right leg discomfort. Additionally, Tigers legend Miguel Cabrera was notably snubbed from The Athletic's MLB All-Quarter Century team despite his iconic career achievements, likely due to his playing multiple positions rather than excelling at a single one. These discussions reflect ongoing debates about player value, defensive skills, offensive production, and career impact across MLB.