Carrie Underwood Faces Fan Backlash Over American Idol Finale Performance, Reaction

Carrie Underwood, who joined the 'American Idol' judging panel in Season 23, has faced significant backlash from fans and viewers throughout the season, with criticisms focusing on her perceived lack of enthusiasm and apparent bias against winner Jamal Roberts. Some fans accused her of being disinterested and politically controversial, particularly after a behind-the-scenes video showed her singing Whitney Houston's 'I Wanna Dance With Somebody,' which some felt was disrespectful due to Underwood's political affiliations. Despite this, Underwood publicly congratulated Roberts on his victory, though some fans viewed this as damage control. Additionally, there is an ongoing tension between Underwood and former judge Katy Perry, who is reportedly seeking to reclaim her spot amid declining ratings attributed in part to Underwood's tenure. Supporters have defended Underwood, appreciating her unique contributions and constructive feedback on the show. However, with the show's ratings fluctuating and fan sentiment divided, Underwood's future as a judge remains uncertain.