Paul Scholes Slams Manchester United Summer Transfer Failures After 3-0 City Defeat

Paul Scholes has strongly criticized Manchester United's transfer strategy during the summer, describing the failure to sign goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma as a 'criminal offence' and highlighting the club's neglect of key positions like central midfield and goalkeeper. Despite spending over £200 million predominantly on attacking players, United have struggled, winning only once in their first five games and suffering a heavy 3-0 defeat to Manchester City as well as an early Carabao Cup exit to Grimsby Town. Scholes contends that the quality of players, particularly in midfield and goalkeeping, is insufficient to compete at the highest level, and questions the emphasis on signing multiple forwards rather than addressing these critical areas. While manager Ruben Amorim insists on maintaining his preferred 3-4-3 system despite the poor results, Scholes believes the underlying issue lies with recruitment rather than tactical formations. United’s board remains publicly supportive of Amorim, advocating a long-term rebuilding approach, but frustrations are mounting among fans and some senior players. Scholes’ comments underscore a growing consensus that urgent changes in player quality and transfer priorities are needed for Manchester United to improve their dismal start to the season.