The San Francisco Giants are in a pivotal offseason after moving on from president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi and appointing Buster Posey. Despite a lackluster performance in 2024, finishing just under .500, the team is under pressure to make significant moves to compete in a tough division. Star closer Camilo Doval is drawing trade interest from several teams, despite a disappointing 2024 season that saw his ERA rise to 4.88. His prior success as a 2023 All-Star, with a career ERA+ of 121, makes him a valuable asset, raising questions about whether the Giants should trade him or attempt to rehabilitate his performance. The organization must weigh the potential of Doval's recovery against the benefits of acquiring cost-controlled players to address roster needs. This offseason will be crucial for the Giants as they navigate their future direction and team composition.